Mobile Apps
· AppRequests Editorial Team

AppRequests is an independent mobile app comparison platform. We may earn a commission when you click through.

The Fitness Apps Worth Keeping After the First Week

A community-picked guide to running, gym logs, nutrition, and health data, with honest notes on platform limits, ratings, and paid features.

Advertisement

Quick Picks for People Who Want a Fitness App They’ll Actually Use

This list is for people who care about consistent tracking, useful feedback, and fewer subscription surprises. Generic fitness roundups usually mix calorie counters, smartwatch dashboards, and workout logs as if they solve the same problem. They do not.

The community request list pointed to a clearer split: Garmin Connect™ for device owners, ASICS Runkeeper for runners, Hevy for gym progression, and Health Connect for Android data sharing. Healthify and MyFitnessPal cover nutrition, but their value depends heavily on how much manual logging you can tolerate.

Best overall for training data: Garmin Connect™.
Best for runners: ASICS Runkeeper.
Best for gym logging: Hevy.
Best for connecting Android health data: Health Connect.

Abstract community-curated fitness app selection

For Training Data That Goes Beyond Step Counts

The strongest apps in this group are not generic motivation tools. They become useful when they turn repeated activity into a record you can review, compare, and act on.

Garmin Connect

Garmin Connect™ is the most capable pick here, but only if you own a compatible Garmin device such as a Forerunner, Venu, or fēnix. The app can review tracked activities and health metrics, create workouts, and build courses. That hardware requirement is the dividing line: Garmin owners get a central training dashboard, while everyone else gets very little from the app alone. The community requested it because it connects race preparation with broader health tracking, not because it is a useful standalone download.

You will stay on this site

ASICS Runkeeper

ASICS Runkeeper is the cleaner recommendation for runners who do not want a smartwatch ecosystem to dominate the experience. The App Store listing shows a 4.7 rating from 140 ratings, plus a free download with in-app purchases. Compared with Garmin Connect, it is more focused: running routes, activity tracking, and training motivation rather than a broad device dashboard. The limitation is equally straightforward—its public listing does not show a fully free feature breakdown, so check the subscription prompts before building a plan around paid tools.

You will stay on this site

Hevy

Hevy takes the opposite approach from Runkeeper: it is about recording gym sessions rather than mapping outdoor activity. That narrower purpose is its advantage for lifters who want a repeatable log of exercises, sets, and progress. The supplied listing identifies it as a workout tracker, but does not provide a price or rating, so the honest verdict is based on fit rather than a claimed popularity score. Pick it over Garmin Connect if your main question is whether you lifted more than last week, not how far you ran.

You will stay on this site

Health Connect

Health Connect is less of a workout coach and more of a data traffic controller. Android describes it as a way to share information between health, fitness, and wellbeing apps, with access through Settings or Quick Settings. That makes it unusually useful beside Hevy, Healthify, or another tracker, but underwhelming as a standalone fitness destination. The privacy angle matters too: its purpose is controlled data sharing, so review which apps can read or write health information instead of granting access automatically.

You will stay on this site

Garmin Connect and Runkeeper help you interpret activity; Hevy records strength work; Health Connect helps Android apps exchange the data. None replaces the others cleanly, which is why the right pick depends more on your training habit than on download popularity.

Nutrition Tracking Without Pretending It’s Effortless

Food apps promise clarity, but the real cost is attention. The better question is not how many foods are in a database; it is whether you will still log meals on a busy Thursday.

Abstract nutrition tracking app concepts

Healthify

Healthify: AI Diet & Fitness is the broadest nutrition-led entry in the group. Its listing claims more than 40 million users and highlights AI-powered health insights, meal tracking, and fitness support. That scale makes it the community’s most obvious pick for people who want food and activity in one place, but the marketing language is much stronger than the supplied evidence on pricing or free-tier limits. Treat the AI as a logging aid, not a medical authority, and check which coaching features require payment before committing.

You will stay on this site

MyFitnessPal

MyFitnessPal is the more established-feeling alternative for people who want calories, macros, food, workouts, and water tracking in one account. Its listing calls the database comprehensive and includes personalized goals, but it does not state a price in the supplied data. That missing detail matters because a large free download can still reserve its most useful analysis for paid members. I would choose it over Healthify for users who already know they will log meals manually; I would not recommend either app to someone who hates food entry.

You will stay on this site

The surprising split is between claimed breadth and sustainable use. Healthify advertises a user base above 40 million, while MyFitnessPal emphasizes the number of tracking categories. Neither fact proves that logging will stick. The app you keep is the one that asks for less friction at the exact moment your routine gets messy.

Useful Extras, With Clear Limits

Two community-requested apps deserve attention, but neither belongs in the same lane as a running tracker or gym log. One organizes Apple Health data; the other centers on scale readings and clinic-led lifestyle monitoring.

Apple Health App

HealthView: Apple Health App is a dashboard layer for Apple Health data rather than a complete training plan. The App Store listing shows a 5.0 rating from only 5 ratings, so that score is encouraging but far too small to treat as proof of broad reliability. Its free download includes in-app purchases, and the title points to dashboards and widgets as the core use. Choose it when your problem is scattered health information; choose Runkeeper or Hevy when your problem is actually planning workouts.

You will stay on this site

MovingLife

MovingLife is a specialist tool for Bluetooth scale data. The listing describes automatic transmission, saved health records, graphs, and standard-range judgments, with support for saving data to Apple Health. That is useful for someone already using the compatible scale, but it is not a general fitness app and should not be judged against Runkeeper or MyFitnessPal. The community request makes sense for connected-scale owners; everyone else can skip it without losing a workout feature.

You will stay on this site

These two apps expose a common trap in fitness roundups: a dashboard, a scale companion, and a training tracker can all sit under “health,” yet solve completely different problems. Check the hardware and platform first. A five-star score from five ratings is not stronger evidence than a 4.7 score from 140 ratings simply because the number looks cleaner.

What to Avoid Before You Install

  • Do not install Garmin Connect without compatible Garmin hardware. Its core value depends on pairing a supported device.
  • Do not confuse a data hub with a coach. Health Connect moves information between apps; it does not replace a training plan.
  • Do not treat AI nutrition claims as clinical advice. Healthify’s AI features may help with logging, but the listing does not establish medical accuracy.
  • Do not overread tiny rating samples. HealthView’s 5.0 rating comes from 5 ratings, while Runkeeper’s 4.7 comes from 140.
  • Check paid features before building a routine. Runkeeper, HealthView, FITTR, Healthify, and MyFitnessPal are listed as free with in-app purchases or do not disclose enough pricing detail in the supplied data to call the free tier generous.

Quick Comparison

AppBest forPlatform signalMonetization signalMain limitation
Garmin Connect™Garmin device ownersAndroid listing suppliedNot providedRequires compatible Garmin hardware
ASICS RunkeeperRunnersiPhone listing suppliedFree with in-app purchasesPaid feature boundaries are not shown here
HevyGym loggingAndroid listing suppliedNot providedPrice and rating not supplied
Health ConnectAndroid data sharingAndroid listing suppliedNot providedNot a workout planner
HealthifyAI-assisted nutrition trackingAndroid listing suppliedPricing not suppliedAI claims need independent scrutiny
MyFitnessPalManual calorie and macro loggingAndroid listing suppliedPricing not suppliedLogging can become tedious
HealthViewApple Health dashboardsiPhone listing suppliedFree with in-app purchasesOnly 5 ratings shown
MovingLifeBluetooth scale ownersAndroid listing suppliedNot providedNeeds compatible scale hardware
Abstract comparison of fitness and health apps

The Apps Worth Keeping

Pick Garmin Connect™ if you already own Garmin hardware and want one place for activities, health metrics, workouts, and courses. Pick ASICS Runkeeper if running is the habit you are trying to protect. For strength training, Hevy is the more focused tool.

Choose Health Connect as the quiet Android layer behind other apps, not as your coach. Nutrition users should start with MyFitnessPal or Healthify only after deciding how much manual logging they will actually sustain. HealthView and MovingLife are sensible specialist downloads for Apple Health dashboards and Bluetooth scales, respectively.

The community asked for apps that remain useful after the novelty fades. The honest test is simple: match the app to the data you already collect, check the paid boundaries, and skip anything that requires hardware or logging you will not maintain.

You might also like

More articles